Chew Blend: @ChrisN

Status
Not open for further replies.

ChrisN

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 21, 2021
Messages
261
Points
93
Location
Peoria IL
Hi,
I am trying to put together a chew blend. Was wondering if I have some plants that would blend well with Small Stalk Black Mammoth to make a chew blend or which plants I should get?
I have Small Stalk Black Mammoth and have been reading/wondering if Havana 142 and TN90 or Green brior would work well? I have:

Caribbean blend
Cuban criollo 98
Havana 142
Habano 2000
Florida Sumatra
Connecticut broadleaf

Full flavor cigarette blend
Catterton
Shirey
Green brior
Symbol 4
Prilep

401 Cherry Red
DR Olor
DR Piloto Cubano
TN90
Turkish Izmir Ozbas
Havana 608

Thank you very much!
 

Jbg

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2020
Messages
113
Points
43
Location
Arkansas
Chew is nearly all air cured tobaccos. Personally I would probably use dark air and burley and maybe some Orientals probably prilep and/or basma.
 

plantdude

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 6, 2020
Messages
909
Points
93
Location
Arkansas
I posted a recipe on the "what did you chew today" thread if you are interested in a chew style similar to grizzly long cut wintergreen. For something more similar to Copenhagen add some fire cured tobacco, grind it finer, and add a lot less water and glycerin.

You can use any types of tobacco you want depending on what style or taste you are going for. Since I typically flavor mine so much I use anything that is not going to be cigar worthy (i.e. excessive holes) , but do try to keep my overall proportion of orientals on the low side (not much contribution to the nicotine level and their delicate flavor and aroma tend to get masked by the flavoring).
From your list I've used Habano 2000, Fl Sumatra, and Connecticut broadleaf before with good results - I think about any cigar variety will work well. I do like to include a fair amount of staghorn and madole and will be incorporating some small stalk black mammoth after this years grow (haven't tried that one yet, but it's listed as good for chew on @skychaser website).
You can use tobacco that has cured green and hasn't aged as long if you are going with strong flavoring and longer cooking times, but properly aged and cured tobaco gives better results. Given the nature of chew I try to avoid any tobacco that is moldy or has had pesticides used on it. I think if you can find a few varieties that give you a good yield and color cure easily in your location without molding they will be good staples to develop your recipe around.
 

ChrisN

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 21, 2021
Messages
261
Points
93
Location
Peoria IL
Thank you very much, plantdude, tullius, and jbg!
That’s great that cigar types should work well in the blend. I’m thinking I’ll use Havana 142 because it sounds like it’s used often in blending. I’m also gathering that the use of rich/full flavored tobacco is what’s best in making chew.
Which do you like the best staghorn or madole? In a way, I’m kinda leaning towards staghorn as it sounds hardier and easier to work with. Would you want to blend the staghorn with the small stalk black mammoth?
I’m also planning to get some corojo 99 and Ohio Dutch so if you think those would work better then staghorn or others just let me know. Trying to narrow it down to the few best ones as the choices are endless lol. I guess the best question would be is there a more traditional chew blend and what would those species likely be?
 

plantdude

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 6, 2020
Messages
909
Points
93
Location
Arkansas
Either staghorn or madole...or both. Depends what else you use it for. Staghorn is a prime chew variety but is also good for pipe and cigars. It cures to a nice red colored leaf with a pleasant flavor and has a nice smoking quality and flavor. Madole is traditionally a variety that is more used for cigars and can be fired cured. It's a bit stronger flavored and air cures dark brown, but still is in commercial production today, which is impressive for an heirloom variety. Both are good multipurpose tobaccos. As far as what is the best, that comes down to personal preference and there are tons of other possibilities out there as well. Hence the suggestion to find something you like that grows well in your area and color cures easily without molding. Find a few varities that give you plenty to work with and aren't a pain to cure and age properly in your location then build from there.
With chew the varieties matter, but I think a lot of it comes down to mouth feel, strength, and the extra flavoring that is added for what most people are after.
I have used Corojo 99 and little Dutch in chew as well. Both work well but I tend to covet those for cigars, to me their flavor tends to stand out more in cigars than in over flavored chew. Both are excellent in cigars, and I have plenty of other varieties that I'm more willing to sacrifice to chew.
 

ChrisN

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 21, 2021
Messages
261
Points
93
Location
Peoria IL
Thank you very much, plantdude! I greatly appreciate it. Helps out a lot. I completely understand about personal preference and what grows best/cures well. This was basically my first year growing. I have lots of learning to do and discover. I really appreciated the already made blends that Northwood Seeds offers. It really helps narrow it down. Otherwise, I can see how this could be overwhelming or not sure what to do and needing guidance. I don't have enough money nor room to have 70 plus different species of tobacco to see how it goes and what I like lol. I have definitely narrowed it down to staghorn and of course small stalk black mammoth. I have enough cigar things. I am sure madole is good but I am happy with what I have or will be getting. There is only a couple plants that mention anything about chew, snus, etc. One of those plants is Greenwood. Have you tried it?
I will for sure keep Corojo 99 and dutch just for cigars. I really enjoy corojo but have never tried ohio dutch. Though what I have read/heard sounds great and looking forward to trying it.
 

deluxestogie

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
May 25, 2011
Messages
26,621
Points
113
Location
near Blacksburg, VA
Dark classed tobacco varieties are often used for smokeless recipes. Each has its advantages and disadvantages.

DARK
  • Adonis
  • Ainaro
  • Bolivian Criollo Black
  • Goose Creek Red
  • Greenwood
  • India Black
  • Liquiça
  • Little Yellow
  • Madole
  • One Sucker (there are over a dozen different ones)
  • Rot Front
  • Shirey
  • Small Stalk Black Mammoth
  • Staghorn
  • Szamosi Dark
  • Tabaco Negro (Spain)
  • VA 355
  • Viqueque
  • Walker's Broadleaf
Bob
 

ChrisN

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 21, 2021
Messages
261
Points
93
Location
Peoria IL
I think I might try and see what Shirey is like with Staghorn and small stalk black mammoth. That way I just get Staghorn with Corojo 99 and Ohio Dutch and go from there.
 

plantdude

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 6, 2020
Messages
909
Points
93
Location
Arkansas
I've never tried shirey, keep us posted on your thoughts. Little Dutch and Ohio Dutch are two different varieties and may or may not be similar, I can't tell you since I've never grown Ohio Dutch. Little Dutch is one of my personal favorites though for flavor and aroma. I've had a rough year with a drought but surprisingly even in our southern heat Little Dutch has performed miracously in my area reaching 3.5 feet and being much more robust in the heat and drought than many varieties I thought would do better. Maybe @skychaser or someone more familiar with Ohio Dutch can give you a comparison between the two for flavor.
I have yet to try greenwood either so can't comment on that, but I do look forward to your experience with it. Staghorn is one I don't think you will go wrong with. I'm hoping small stalk black mammoth blends well since it my first year growing it, but with our drought this year it's not been one of my better yielding varities so far. I keep my favorites going each year but I love to try a handful of new types every year just to see how they do. For me the fun is in growing them.

Just as a note for @tullius - I have tried yellow twist bud (mild burley) and harrow velvet (medium strength burley) in chew before and they work well. After two years of growing them the only downside is even though they look like they could be good yielding varities in a northern location I don't think they make it to their full potential here in the southern heat - tend to be on the smaller side. Canadian developed varieties probably weren't my best choice for the southern US, but hey, you never know until you try right... They cure easy though, which keeps me coming back to them.
 

ChrisN

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 21, 2021
Messages
261
Points
93
Location
Peoria IL
Thank you very much, plantdude! Very interesting, will for sure keep that in mind with the Little Dutch. Here in Central IL we experience lack of rain sometimes as well. This year was slightly better then others until August. All of a sudden August was somewhat dry. I probably won't get Greenwood but I'm for sure getting Staghorn. I will for sure share my thoughts with Shirey and if I end up getting Ohio Dutch. I also enjoy trying new types and growing them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top