First Cigar

Status
Not open for further replies.

FmGrowit

Head Honcho
Staff member
Joined
May 17, 2011
Messages
5,313
Points
113
Location
Freedom, Ohio, United States
I have question about drying the cigar and draw..as soon as you stop drawing they all go-out

by the way they were rolled with several differnt tobaccos from diff sources all have same promblem??

Randy

Hello Steve;

thanks Don and Steve for reply...but I have to disagree with you guys here.first filler was very low case crumbly actual and Ilet the cigars air-out for abt week Im thing bad tobacco

The first thing I thought of when I started reading your first post was the tobacco was improperly grown and/or cured, but the chance of getting several tobaccos from different sources ALL with the same burning problem is quite unlikely...unless everyone you got tobacco from learned how to grow and cure it from the same person.

The only thing I can recommend is not to buy tobacco from whomever it was you bought your tobacco from....and let the tobacco dry out more before you try to roll with it.

Regarding the cost you've incurred for bad tobacco versus buying a bunch of cigars....a pound of tobacco will roll about 30 cigars. A pound of good cigar tobacco costs about $20...that's about 65¢ per stick. You can't get a Swisher Sweet for that.
 

SmokesAhoy

Moderator
Founding Member
Joined
May 22, 2011
Messages
2,686
Points
63
Location
VT
a bad homegrown compares favorably to a cheaper cigar, it's a better taste but has issues like you mentioned. normally it's just bad due to not being aged enough and also learning curve of making cigar. newbie cigars usually look awesome, but draw poor, as you get better they look like shit but draw great, as you get better (and i'm not there yet) they look great and taste great.

you probably made a pretty cigar that drew like crap with tobaccos that needed more processing or something. just keep on doing more, perhaps get dons sampler, roll 1 smoke one, rinse and repeat.

when everyone starts too much emphasis is put on how it looks, who wants to post a picture of something that looks like a loose turd? but at the beginning those are the ones that smoke the best.

i just got inside from smoking a cigar that used BarG's silver river as a wrapper and my spearhead as a filler, it actually looked nicer than normal purely because barg's silver river is some pristine looking stuff, it drew good, tasted great etc. it was loose because it wasnt formed and the head was not glued down, but for a smoke you roll and use it was great. just work on making more that draw nicely, there are all kinds of issues that happen to new rollers for a ton of reasons, but as you do more, somehow those issues go away even though it seems you are doing the same thing as when you started.
 

BarG

Founding Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2011
Messages
5,120
Points
113
Location
Texas, Brazos Vally
I haven't tried the silver river as a wrapper yet. I still have not rolled 2 cigars that were the same.:rolleyes: I'm glad you liked it SmokesAhoy. The last leaves I harvested from my silver river[quite a few upper middles] were severely damaged by hornworms due to my absense, but It is a very robust producer and I got a lot of leaves from 24 plants.

Randy, I'll send a sample of some that just came out of the kiln soon. I have been sampling and I believe some of it still needs to rest [A phrase from Deluxstogie] A little while. I take it to mean that some varietys improve fresh out of the kiln within a week or 2. Ive been very impressed with the Havana 425 and the Ct. Broadleaf for my first kiln attempt.
 

deluxestogie

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
May 25, 2011
Messages
26,625
Points
113
Location
near Blacksburg, VA
On the subject of cigar rolling expertise:

I've rolled over 3000 cigars. Whoopee! If I were employed in a cigar factory in, say, Nicaragua, the other employees would likely whisper something like, "He's enthusiastic, and his ugly cigars smoke pretty good, but he's just a newbie. He's only been doing it for about 2 weeks. Give him some time, and he'll get better."

In many cigar factories, cigar rollers are expected to turn out ~300 cigars a day. I roll ~3 to 5 cigars a day. So, I've racked up all of about 2 work-weeks of experience. At my level of inexperience, I can usually (not always) roll a cigar that looks semi-presentable, and draws and burns fairly well. With extra care and concentration, I can roll a truly beautiful cigar about 1/3 of the times that I go for beauty, which I don't bother with very often.

All that having been said, I could reliably roll a smokable, ugly cigar only after the first 30 or so attempts.

Bob
 

Randy

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2012
Messages
253
Points
0
Location
Madison TN
Thanks guys for response on issue I was just very frustrated last nite with first rolls not staying lit..to big of hurry to smoke a cigar I guess..by no means im I giving-up on this new hobby of growing and rolling my own cigars..kinda like a kid who finally gets that trainset and in rush to put together let-out somthing and didnt work..first you get mad and blame the track.then next day start all over again and learn from your mistake {or you throw it out the window..lol..Ive done that}..but now more than before Im gonea whip this thing to I get it rite!!

Randy

edit.. for the record the tobacco I used was NOT from any member here..few weeks ago I ordered from some sit.it was some kind-of PA grown burley I belive.
 

johnlee1933

Moderator
Founding Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2011
Messages
3,970
Points
0
Location
Near Danbury, CT
lookin tasty there Don! Tim, What did you think of that Havana puro? I have one in my humidor that I'm considering lighting up tonight
I love my Havana puro's. That's mostly what I smoke now. I was just asking Bob about "flavor" adjusting strips.

J
 

deluxestogie

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
May 25, 2011
Messages
26,625
Points
113
Location
near Blacksburg, VA
Randy,
If the leaf you ordered was from this year's crop, and was not kilned, then it's probably not yet ready. Burley that is only color-cured, and not either kilned or aged for a season, still contains a lot of carbohydrates and proteins that will char, and promptly extinguish a cigar. This is remedied by aging or kilning, allowing it to burn much better.

Bob
 

Randy

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2012
Messages
253
Points
0
Location
Madison TN
Bob I think you just solved my problem..the tobacco was JUST color-cured only I do belive!!! thats what I was refering to bad tobacco ..maybe shouldnt said "bad" shoulkd have said not aged

Randy
 

marksctm

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2012
Messages
451
Points
0
Location
South West Ohio
Well I rolled cigars #2 and #3 last night, I'll see if they smoke any better than my first fire proof cigar. I did use some of the burley I toasted in them.
On some of the cigar rolling videos, some rollers I've seen start with 2 binders on top of each other, any better rolling that way, or is that the way pro's do it?
Also I saw a roller stack 2 rappers on each other, one rapper dark leaf, and one a light leaf, off set about a half inch, and when it was rolled, it looked like, and was called a barber pole.
Any body hear of a barber pole cigar?


cigar 3_0004.jpg cigar 3_0001.jpg cigar 3_0005.jpg cigar 2_0001.jpg cigar 2_0002.jpg
 

DonH

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2012
Messages
1,609
Points
0
Location
Massachusetts
I just started rolling cigars. I used Dark Air Cured 2nd and 3rd priming, TN 90 Burley, and YTB as filler and Bezuki for the wrapper and binder for my first try. I ended up rolling two because I overestimated how much tobacco would be needed. My filler was too dry, so I had trouble bunching it and the cigar ended up way too spongy. Very soft. I put them in the humidor overnight and smoked one the next day. It was OK.

The next night I tried again and put the filler in higher case. This time the filler was Dark Air 3rd, Burley, and some Bezuki scraps from the night before. I brought the filler to low/medium case so I could flatten the strips, then rolled them up together. I used YTB for binder, because the YTP I have are nice big leaves. This time the result was much better, but a little too tight. I cut the cigar in half and got a better draw. This time the taste was fantastic. I still have a half left that I may dry out then put in the humidor to see if that improves the draw.

I will try again tonight. First time too loose, second time too tight, maybe the third time will do the trick.

How do the pros get the cigars to draw well while they are packed tight? I have some small Nicaraguan cigars (Placencia Organica) in my humidor and they are packed way tighter than the one I packed a little too tight, yet they draw well.
 

Knucklehead

Moderator
Founding Member
Joined
Oct 18, 2012
Messages
12,777
Points
113
Location
NE Alabama

DonH

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2012
Messages
1,609
Points
0
Location
Massachusetts
Another question. I know some people roll and smoke. Others dry first. Is it best to dry the cigar first, then put it in a humidor, or, if the filler is in low case just roll and smoke?

I noticed last night when I decided to re-roll the loose cigar that the extremely low case filler, after sitting in the high case wrapper in the humidor, was in medium case. Just wondering how people do this? Roll and smoke, roll dry and humidify, or roll and humidify?
 

johnlee1933

Moderator
Founding Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2011
Messages
3,970
Points
0
Location
Near Danbury, CT
Another question. I know some people roll and smoke. Others dry first. Is it best to dry the cigar first, then put it in a humidor, or, if the filler is in low case just roll and smoke?

I noticed last night when I decided to re-roll the loose cigar that the extremely low case filler, after sitting in the high case wrapper in the humidor, was in medium case. Just wondering how people do this? Roll and smoke, roll dry and humidify, or roll and humidify?
IMO there are as many answers to that as there are home rollers. I like mine dry. Many disagree and want different levels of moisture. There are those who swear sitting in a humidor for "n" years makes a better smoke. My taste buds aren't that discriminating. As with many things play around till you get what you like. i.e. I like my cigars a bit softer than the commercial ones I used to smoke. -- John
 

Knucklehead

Moderator
Founding Member
Joined
Oct 18, 2012
Messages
12,777
Points
113
Location
NE Alabama
I do both. If I'm trying a new blend I'll smoke it right then. If I roll a few of a blend I like I'll put some in the humidor for later. I have heard that letting a fresh rolled cigar sit for several days or weeks allows the flavors from the different blends to meld with each other and also in the humidor for awhile it has a consistent moisture throughout. Try both ways, you may end up doing both or you may decide you like one way better. The best choice is the one that works for you.
 

Bika

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2012
Messages
80
Points
0
Location
Dallas Tx
My first Cigar tasted a bit leafy still. So ill keep them fermintating a bit longer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top