Hey! Knock it off!

Status
Not open for further replies.

webmost

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2013
Messages
1,908
Points
113
Location
Newark DE
To all you guys growing lush green gardens full of tall plants, all I gotta say, as a confirmed black thumb, is Hey! Knock it off! I can't grow mold on siding. I can, however, kill dandelions at twenty paces. You guys, you're just showing off.

So, anyways, I was looking at a Nat Geo article the other day, where various botanists are trying to prove that plants are conscious. Some claim to have shown that plants know when you are standing near, or if their neighbor has beetles, or if you are playing Bach. Course, the big prob with reading plants minds is that their reactions are so patiently delivered. So a feller devised an experiment using potted shrinking mimosas, cause the leaves will collapse if the plant feels threatened. He dropped a number of these mimosas a couple feet. Onto a cushion, tho, so they wouldn't get hurt. First few times, the plants would wilt all down, like you'd expect. After half a dozen times or so, they stopped shrinking, cause they figured out the guy wasn't going to hurt them. After that, he could drop them all day and they didn't care. Now here's the kicker: He discovered he could let them sit on the window sill a month or two, go back, and drop them again... and guess what? They remembered! They still knew he wasn't going to drop them on pavement and crack their pot or anything. Memory. If that isn't consciousness, I dunno what is.

So this article got me all curious... Here's my question:

You go back to pick your cucumbers, do you get any sense that the plant says: "Oh Schidt! Here comes the monster that steals my ovaries!" You go out to harvest your tobacco leaf by leaf, do you get any sense by the time you get up to viso that the plant says: "Hey, Big Guy! Knock it off! I'm trying to grow here!"
 

deluxestogie

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
May 25, 2011
Messages
26,609
Points
113
Location
near Blacksburg, VA
I heartily recommend the small (192 page) book by Chamovitz, What a Plant Knows: http://www.amazon.com/What-Plant-Knows-Field-Senses/dp/0374533881/

Tobacco looks forward to being smoked. I always prime my cigar leaf while smoking a cigar. It inspires them to produce richer, darker leaf. Their goal is to be worthy of becoming a cigar, rather than being condemned to the shredder. If you're a tobacco plant, that's what you do. And they are clearly grateful for not having to grow along the slopes of the Andes (or in Delaware). They know that Virginia is a tobacco-friendly place.

As for music, they're not real keen on show tunes or tenor arias. But they do seem partial to Tangerine Dream and Jean Michel Jarre. Hip-hop causes chronic etch and frenching.

Bob
 

deluxestogie

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
May 25, 2011
Messages
26,609
Points
113
Location
near Blacksburg, VA
Maybe it's just my voice. Che gelida manina didn't do it for them. But the neighbor's goats actually sang along.

Bob
 

chillardbee

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 29, 2013
Messages
888
Points
63
Location
Chilliwack BC, Canada (south western Canada)
It might be very well that plants know that they grow, not only to reproduce, but to serve use as foods and medicines. Maybe tobacco looks forward to being primed and maybe thats why a ripe leaf breaks crisp as celery...and as we walk away with a bundle of leaves, they're saying "Enjoy the fruits of our labor".
 

webmost

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2013
Messages
1,908
Points
113
Location
Newark DE
It might be very well that plants know that they grow, not only to reproduce, but to serve use as foods and medicines. Maybe tobacco looks forward to being primed and maybe thats why a ripe leaf breaks crisp as celery...and as we walk away with a bundle of leaves, they're saying "Enjoy the fruits of our labor".

... I can almost hear the old Aztecs now, smugly remarking among themselves: "It might very well be that those Tlascalans look forward to the next xochiyaoyotl, when their hearts will be sacrificed to Huitzilopochtli."

No, I doubt any sentient being is apt to be be glad their tongues get ripped off and burnt, much less their ovaries plucked to slice down for salad.

Question is, gardeners, do they send you any such smoke signals? The pig screams bloody murder. You can hear him a mile away. Who hears the corn? Question might have sounded absurd, up until you prove consciousness and even memory in a potted plant.
 

chillardbee

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 29, 2013
Messages
888
Points
63
Location
Chilliwack BC, Canada (south western Canada)
I like to think that we have a symbiotic relationship with our plant life. I refer more to the sustainable aproach of farming then to big agro-biz. True, plants may not need human intervention but then again, the likeliness of any number of crops to continue for generations to come are better when we can show some husbandry and stewardship in maintaining the land, harvesting seeds for next crops, and keeping pests and disease at bay.
 

Birage

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2015
Messages
60
Points
0
Location
Birdsboro, Pennsylvania
Well, if we are talking about how smart a plant or animal is in conjunction to our need to kill and consume them, I saw on Nat Geo that pigs were four times smarter than dogs, yet we kill and butcher pigs by the millions, not so with dogs. Tobacco could be in relative terms as smart as a pig! And grass could be stupid and we let it live!
 

webmost

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2013
Messages
1,908
Points
113
Location
Newark DE
Hey, I'm not trying to make it ethical. I am glad to stick any pig. Let him squeal, long as he tastes good. I used to keep goats. Bets pets ever... and good eating. If you are what you eat, then love em and eat em, I say.

I'm only wondering whether you, who are close to your plants, and who have a knack to make them thrive, have a sense that they squeak too. The mimosa experiment intrigued me.
 

deluxestogie

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
May 25, 2011
Messages
26,609
Points
113
Location
near Blacksburg, VA
...plants...they squeak too.[?]
They don't. Plants exhibit no actions that could be attributable to their being self-aware, or capable of "anticipation." The sensory-motor responses of plants, as well as their usually quite transient "memory," operates on a time scale suitable for their relative lack of mobility. If you're really mobile, you need the complexity of a brain to avoid bumbing into things.

Bob
 

USHOG

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 30, 2014
Messages
240
Points
0
Location
Iola, Texas
But imagine the level of communication between plants since they can not move. Millions of years to evolve communication

Weather they have a conscious or just react to stimuli they do respond and we all watch. As we pick the flowers off of our tobacco to force the plant to make more nicotine or bigger leaves. This is only a counter measure to an attack on the plant and they all do it in some sort of fashion or they die. If an aphid outbreak occurs who do you think calls the lady bugs?
 

USHOG

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 30, 2014
Messages
240
Points
0
Location
Iola, Texas
I also do not know about anticipation every morning my sun flowers are facing east waiting for the sun. I use to play with moving my light to 4 different spots 90 degrees apart over a 4 day period. After several weeks the sun flower would wait to track where the light was going to come on at and it knew the schedule. It was very weird to me. Kind of like cows and magnetic fields. There is just so much we do not understand
 

Smokin Harley

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
2,579
Points
63
Location
Grant ,Alabama
To all you guys growing lush green gardens full of tall plants, all I gotta say, as a confirmed black thumb, is Hey! Knock it off! I can't grow mold on siding. I can, however, kill dandelions at twenty paces. You guys, you're just showing off.

So, anyways, I was looking at a Nat Geo article the other day, where various botanists are trying to prove that plants are conscious. Some claim to have shown that plants know when you are standing near, or if their neighbor has beetles, or if you are playing Bach. Course, the big prob with reading plants minds is that their reactions are so patiently delivered. So a feller devised an experiment using potted shrinking mimosas, cause the leaves will collapse if the plant feels threatened. He dropped a number of these mimosas a couple feet. Onto a cushion, tho, so they wouldn't get hurt. First few times, the plants would wilt all down, like you'd expect. After half a dozen times or so, they stopped shrinking, cause they figured out the guy wasn't going to hurt them. After that, he could drop them all day and they didn't care. Now here's the kicker: He discovered he could let them sit on the window sill a month or two, go back, and drop them again... and guess what? They remembered! They still knew he wasn't going to drop them on pavement and crack their pot or anything. Memory. If that isn't consciousness, I dunno what is.

So this article got me all curious... Here's my question:

You go back to pick your cucumbers, do you get any sense that the plant says: "Oh Schidt! Here comes the monster that steals my ovaries!" You go out to harvest your tobacco leaf by leaf, do you get any sense by the time you get up to viso that the plant says: "Hey, Big Guy! Knock it off! I'm trying to grow here!"

Funny you say this...as I was replanting my first seedlings ,I punched up some Cuban music on Spotify...maybe thats why they grew so much better than the other ones...they "remembered" and appreciated that I thought of their heritage.
 

Chicken

redneck grower
Founding Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
4,631
Points
83
Location
FLORIDA
Plants love me..i bring them tons of Fertilizer daily..
 

chillardbee

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 29, 2013
Messages
888
Points
63
Location
Chilliwack BC, Canada (south western Canada)
Hey, I'm not trying to make it ethical. I am glad to stick any pig. Let him squeal, long as he tastes good.

I never met a pig that didn't taste good. I love my baby back ribs. The other day I put a rack on the barbie with my special sauce over apple wood chips. I also put on a square of beef ribs. Big mistake with the beef ribs because they were AS if not MORE delicious then the pork and now I'll have to buy both when I have my grill night because I'm terrible with decisions.
 

Ben Brand

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Messages
1,170
Points
63
Location
Groblersdal, South Africa
I never met a pig that didn't taste good. I love my baby back ribs. The other day I put a rack on the barbie with my special sauce over apple wood chips. I also put on a square of beef ribs. Big mistake with the beef ribs because they were AS if not MORE delicious then the pork and now I'll have to buy both when I have my grill night because I'm terrible with decisions.
Chillard you dont feel like sharing some of those sauces and rubs with us. I really like smoked meats etc. hasn`t done much smoking myself, but really would like to try my hand at it. Ive got a Dutch oven that I want to make into a smoker.
Ben
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top